After the final episode I started to think about his again. Makes more sense now. Since it seems that all the things on the Island are just for the research. And Fenry coming to the (well Kept) dock on the boat..seems he must have come from somewhere that they could be observing things from afar. With a large telescope and the monitoring cameras.
Lastley..I have come to think that it'[s more like a combo of things. It's maybe a oil rig style place above water, and then there will be an underwater lab for their research in the ocean.
-- Edited by snootch2danootch at 00:50, 2006-05-26
Well here's what I've come up with to add to this.
If the button was being used to divert the Em output so it wouldn't become critical. And the "KEY" that Des used did the same thing how did the two outcomes differ so much??? I think that the button actually does the same thing as the KEY, but instead of the huge noise and vibrations that occured after Des turned the key to release the EM build-up...the Button actually opens some form of conduit that is conected to the island. It collects the power and sends it through the line that leads into the ocean. This is where all of the power on the losties Island and the "underwater hatch (thinking more like a combo of Underwater labs, and an oil rig) is coming from. It's double effiecient... Keeps the Em build-up from getting to great, and also powers all the reasearch facilities that are in the area.
the cable was too small in diameter to be able to carry much in the way of current and/or voltage so i doubt if it was intended for power transfer usage. It is almost certainly a communication cable of some sort, possibly fiber optic, it reminded me of a ocean crossing cable, probably for telephone usuage. You have to remember cables used underwater have to have a very tough outer jacket to handle abrasion and water pressure, water inside the jacket would short out the wiring post haste, this makes the jacket quite thick. I would not be surprised to discover an underwater hatch, that would answer a lot of questions raised along the way. I am still convinced the island's electrical power comes from hydro-electric power generation from dams and reservoirs and as i remember at one point in time they showed two fairly large plumes of water jetting out of the side of a mountain, i think the magnetic fairytale is just one large red herring used as a distraction and false trail.
I cried, "Oh, Lady Midnight, I fear that you grow old, the stars eat your body and the wind makes you cold." "If we cry now," she said, "it will just be ignored."
the cable was too small in diameter to be able to carry much in the way of current and/or voltage so i doubt if it was intended for power transfer usage. It is almost certainly a communication cable of some sort, possibly fiber optic, it reminded me of a ocean crossing cable, probably for telephone usuage. You have to remember cables used underwater have to have a very tough outer jacket to handle abrasion and water pressure, water inside the jacket would short out the wiring post haste, this makes the jacket quite thick. I would not be surprised to discover an underwater hatch, that would answer a lot of questions raised along the way. I am still convinced the island's electrical power comes from hydro-electric power generation from dams and reservoirs and as i remember at one point in time they showed two fairly large plumes of water jetting out of the side of a mountain, i think the magnetic fairytale is just one large red herring used as a distraction and false trail.
volts!!! so glad you made it and thank you for the info... this needs to be more widely known!!!!!!!!!!
Volts..Thanks for joining, and also for shooting my theory apart so early in the offseason For real though...thanks for the info. The cable size makes sense. I was just drawing straws.
I have a good friend who owns an island in lake st. clair in what's known as the flats at the north end of the lake. He has a power cable running underwater from the shore to his island just for his cottage and boathouse and his cable is at least as thick as my forearm and i am a large person. I would guess it's at least four inches in diameter. I really didn't intend to shoot down your theory but i feel that cable has been overplayed and exagerated along the way, i don't feel it has any real importance at all. Being a retired master electrician and electrical contractor i tend to look closely and sceptically at all things electrical shown in the show. Perhaps i should say all things shown in the show, not just the electrical stuff. Too many hard to swallow things for me to be happy.
I cried, "Oh, Lady Midnight, I fear that you grow old, the stars eat your body and the wind makes you cold." "If we cry now," she said, "it will just be ignored."
to some extent yes, modern medicine uses magnetic therapy to treat a variety of problems, ultra-sonic and ultra high frequency radio waves also. They are supposed to promote more rapid healing, particully burns and open wounds and broken bones. I have never had the need to use the above so can't comment on first hand expirence. Sounds sensible to me.
It does seem very likely that it could work for medical means. I know my Uncle swears by his Magnetic Bracelet. He says his arthritis is pretty much history since he started wearing it.
I cried, "Oh, Lady Midnight, I fear that you grow old, the stars eat your body and the wind makes you cold." "If we cry now," she said, "it will just be ignored."
i have a number of magnetic braces and have used them on my back and shoulders when they hurt and it does seem to work wonders... also wrists when theey hurt and when my arm falls asleep... lately i have been using a band on my toe as i sleep and i swear it makes it feel better while it is on.... i believe in the ability of magnets to heal.... and will use them whenever i have a major hurt!!!
I cried, "Oh, Lady Midnight, I fear that you grow old, the stars eat your body and the wind makes you cold." "If we cry now," she said, "it will just be ignored."
someone brought up this question... if pusshing the button releases the magnetic buildup, what happpened with the buildup before the hatch was built????
One of several things i have been racking my feeble brain about is how would a magnet, an electro-magnet, generate electricity to operate all the stuff in the various hatches and where does the electricity come from to power the magnet? If it truly is an electro-magnet it needs electricity to power it. I still think the whole dang island is powered by at least one hydro-electric power generating plant some where on the island. You may remember in some earlier screen caps. they showed two large plumes of water jetting out of the side of the mountain. I suspect this is the discharge from the turbines which are turning the generators, and i suspect there would be at least two generators in case of problems with either one. I can't think of any way a magnet can generate electricity directly. Incidently the history channel had a pretty good one hour program about magnets on modern marvels last night, and i'm pretty sure it will be shown again soon. I will re-visit this subject in the next few days.
I cried, "Oh, Lady Midnight, I fear that you grow old, the stars eat your body and the wind makes you cold." "If we cry now," she said, "it will just be ignored."
what about the energy from heat?? is it posible that it could be thermo power taht generates what's needed for charging the magnets??? and that the button releases the extra heat and not magnetic energy??
Lady, before the hatch was built the magnet probably was not there. I imagine whoever built the hatch built the magnet too, although i can't figure what the purpose was. I just can't figure any reason to install a powerfull electro-magnet in the hatch, i can't understand what the purpose was. That magnet business baffles me completely, I don't have a clue what it was intended to do. That must have cost a small fortune so they must have had a good reason to do so. I would assume the magnet is powered by a capacitor bank and requires somewhere in excess of 108 minutes to charge up. If it is not discharged by that time frame it flashes over and stirs up quite a fuss.
I know I've beaten this to death between here and ABC, but now i'm thinking there was more of a conection between the island and WWII than before. With the most likely location for the island being in the south pacific somewhere. I've always thought that the island was used for military purposes. I'd gather more for a base of operations, and re-fueling place for ships in the big size thoughts, but I'm looking smaller. I have always thought it was a small lookout base. Used to house small groups of forces to disembark to the bigger fights in the south pacific. If the hatch system is indeed connected in some way, but was closed off. Then it would make sense fot it to have been a military instilation at some point in time. Now that I'm in this thought I never did think till just now.....Could it have been originally been used by the Japanese???? They are known for their use of tunnel systems in pretty much every island skirmish they fought. Why not have them make something more akin to what the Germans did along the coasts during WWII.
I'm cutting this up to help keep my mind active to this train of thought...
Now if it was a military base the Magnets could have been installed during the war in an attempt to build some sort of EM weapon. Something to be used on the Allied ships and planes to keep them from attacking their homeland. Could we find out that the only reason that Japan was succesfully bombed by the atom bomb was because the US gain control of the island??
If this is what happened then it's easy to see how the island has ever since been used in one way shape or form. I think it's easy to think that The Hanso Foundation could be involved in things like weapons design. So they could have gotten their foot in the door with the island through that, and then as the cold war ended the US just offered it up to the highest bidder.
OK...I'm reaching, but also giving myself more to think about.
If the electric power generation system is indeed a water powered turbine and generator setup and it could be located the turbines and generators could be examined for manufacture's names and/or trademarks and dates and places of manufacture. I would bet five dollaers vs a stale donut eventually they will admit to this, unfortunately it may be four or five years before they get to that point. I am sure the whole works is/was interconnected with tunnels and pipe/conduit chases, there has to be some way for power, water, sewage, air, and food to be distributed. With most of the installations located underground there would be very little if any need for heating or cooling. If the hatch(cavern) and the equipment therein was actually destroyed the thrust of the storyline will have to shift in a totally different direction.
OK, let's look at thermal power generation and see if it fits. Virtually all thermal generation systems require either natural deep vents down into the earth's crust or deep drilled wells. Water is pumped down into the vents/wells to generate steam, the steam is used to run turbines hooked to generators to make electric power. The condensate water is pumped back down to make more steam. Nothing in this type of system requires anything similar to the timeing set-up in the hatch/cavern. This type of system tends to be self regulating, you merely install a pressure relief valve in the steam line in case of over-pressure. This type of system is self-contained and only requires minimal supervision. The only real maintenance needed would be lubricants for the turbine bearings and the generator bearings. The generator can be air cooled or water cooled.
One thing i think has been mentioned in the past is the extreme logistics involved in building the hatches/caverns/tunnels, etc. is the beaucoup bucks it would take to build everything. Nobody but uncle greedy would have the assets to spend that much moola with no real return of the money. A private corporation would have to be sure of a very good return on the money it spent, and might not have the resources to do it. It would have required many ships, much manpower, much expensive equipment, and they would have had to negotiate with whoever owned the island for the use thereof. I think it is almost 99.999 percent certain that uncle greedy built it in the first go-around.
One thing i think has been mentioned in the past is the extreme logistics involved in building the hatches/caverns/tunnels, etc. is the beaucoup bucks it would take to build everything. Nobody but uncle greedy would have the assets to spend that much moola with no real return of the money. A private corporation would have to be sure of a very good return on the money it spent, and might not have the resources to do it. It would have required many ships, much manpower, much expensive equipment, and they would have had to negotiate with whoever owned the island for the use thereof. I think it is almost 99.999 percent certain that uncle greedy built it in the first go-around.
Nice to see that we are both thinking a bit in the same dirrection. Either The military, or at the very least the Govt.
The internet itself seems to be messed up, all the various yahoo sites were not available or were extremely sluggish all morning. Seems to be getting better now. Maybe another virus or worm atack?
In re- your comment about the japanese using the island, I suppose that is a possibility, however all the electrical switches, fused disconnects, junction boxes, motors, and other pieces of electrical gear I saw had logos of american companies, square d primarily. I would think anyone building something like that would use readily available materials that they were familar with.
In re- your comment about the japanese using the island, I suppose that is a possibility, however all the electrical switches, fused disconnects, junction boxes, motors, and other pieces of electrical gear I saw had logos of american companies, square d primarily. I would think anyone building something like that would use readily available materials that they were familar with.
Very true, but like we've talked about before. It's very possible that at some point Hanso/Dharma came in and upgraded some things. I.E. the tunnels being blocked. Could have been part of a massive upgrade to make things usable for their needs.
Actually, it could have been used by several different groups at different times and revamped as each group needed. It could have been built by the usa, captured by the japs, recaptured by the usa, and turned over to dharma after the war when it was no longer needed, and then maybe abandoned when dharma felt they didn't need it anymore. Make sense?
Actually, it could have been used by several different groups at different times and revamped as each group needed. It could have been built by the usa, captured by the japs, recaptured by the usa, and turned over to dharma after the war when it was no longer needed, and then maybe abandoned when dharma felt they didn't need it anymore. Make sense?-- Edited by voltsandamps at 23:46, 2006-06-24
It does make sense, and that really seems like a better thought than just the basic idea I had. Seems like it could have gine like that, and it was then used as each group needed. That would explain the small differences between some of them. Some were more functional to one group than to the next. So some have been used and upgraded nearly every time it's changed hands, but then others may not have been used at all.
I have been kicking around the idea of an underwater hatch, I can figure how they get electric power, fresh water, food, and other necessities but I can't figure out how they get their air supply, that seems to be the sticky part. I know it is possible to break down seawater into oxygen and hydrogen if you have plenty of power available, submarines do it routinely, at least the nucs. do. There is still something we don't know concerning an underwater hatch, where it is and how it works.